Penny Wise Pound Foolish?

Author: mgiles  |  Category: Accidents, Military

Hawkeye off runway

Hawkeye off runway

Report blames brakes, pilot for E-2C mishap

Bad brakes and pilot error led to an E-2C Hawkeye accident in March in which an aircraft swerved off the runway and sustained more than $10 million in damage.

The Hawkeye was landing after a training flight at Chambers Field in Norfolk, Va., on March 19 when it skidded off the runway and broke its landing gear, according to a Judge Advocate General Manual Investigation report obtained by Navy Times. No one was injured.
From http://www.navytimes.com/news/2009/10/navy_hawkeye_102509w/ Read more…

More From The Experts on AF447

Author: john  |  Category: Accidents, Airlines

Here at the AN we do not know what causes accidents, or even death for that matter. We leave that to the experts. It does appear that victims advised by their lawyers have ventured there, and now read this:
You may need a web page translator to render French to English.

AF447: The crash of Paris-Rio was avoidable

The Union of Airfrance Pilots(SPAF) say in this report, it is the failure of the Pitot probes to measure speed that caused the crash.

Suddenly AF447 is back in the limelight. This will not go away, lawyers are on the case. The Black Box will probably not be found, but if it were ever to be found many anticipate it would simply elucidate the sequence. At some point the ADIRU gave up resulting in a handover to the pilots in impossible conditions.

Nobody knows exactly what happened to AF447 but what we do know is that airspeed measurement is of critical importance when we are flying at great altitude in subsonic airframes. In pilot slang, as you ascend you enter the coffin corner, the apex of which is a point where the aircraft is stalled and exceeding the speed of sound (MACH 1)
simultaneously, hence the name.

Coffin Corner (Wikipedia)

Coffin Corner (Wikipedia)

Here is a simplified graphic of coffin corner courtesy of Wikipedia. With increasing altitude the stall speed increases and the speed of sound decreases. Our long distance RPT jets spend a large percentage of their flight times in the vicinity of this no go point. The fact that jet travel is very safe is testament to the skills of the engineers, scientists and pilots who make all this viable.

Those of us that fly are well familiar with the airspeed pitot system, in fact most of us can tell a story about what went wrong. Insects, dust, ice, covers left on, paint, masking tape, and so on. There have been major RPT catastrophies outside of the coffin corner for these simple reasons. Shit happens, we all know that. The difference with coffin corner is that we are high and fast, a long way from home with poor or no visual reference, and in addition we are stalling or breaking up, all mediated and filtered by a computer which says over to you.

In the great Echo-Chamber of the Internet you will read that we are depending upon the 18th. century technology of Henri Pitot to measure airspeed. In fact there has been a steady development from the time of Darcy in the 19th. century until now. We are committed to subsonic flight for long range RPT, but this pneumatic sensor technology may have hit it’s use by date.

In the very early days the pioneers flew without air speed instruments. The Wrights used a crude angle of attack indicator, Bleriot flew the English Channel with no airspeed instrument. The onset of WW1 encouraged the development of the Pitot-Darcy pitot method of differential air pressure devices to measure air speed in support of the fast and high powered aircraft required to fight a war. The highly developed devices in use today are direct descendents. Essentially they tap ambient air using pitot probes and static ports, measure the pressure difference, then compute and display a calibrated airspeed.

Airspeed measurement technology is in the headlines now, for everybody, not just the aviation buffs.

Lawyers sharpen teeth for AF447

Author: john  |  Category: Accidents, Airlines
AF 447 Wreckage

AF 447 Wreckage

It had to happen and now we see the first move along the feeding chain of aviation litigation for the AF 447 tragedy.

lawyers want EUR1 billion as a starting point for AF447 – victims

The Air France crash on June 1 was the result of a preventable mix of human and technical failures, according to Stewarts Law, a UK law firm representing 50 of the victims’ families

Stewarts Law presented arguments in Paris this week after experts used a simulator to replicate the conditions experienced by the crew of the Airbus A330 in a storm off the coast of Brazil.

The firm wants Air France and Airbus to put the EUR1 billion into a pot to be divided among the families.
Read more…

Death by Computer

Author: mgiles  |  Category: Accidents, Airlines, Human Factors, Opinion, Safety, Speculation

Computer controlled aircraftThere has been a deafening silence in the general press about the AF 447 tragedy of recent times. What with drones running round in various places bombing baddies with the occasional bit of collateral damage generally agreed to be regrettable by the responsible (what a way to use the word) parties and regular suicide bombings not to mention ferries turning over and NSW Cabinet Ministers being laid low by spurned lovers it does not take long for even such a monumental tragedy to fade into the background but those of us who fly are worried and will not rest until some sense can be made of it.
At present the official position is that we do not know the cause but suspect a perfect storm of events starting with a sensor failure led to a loss of control. The more time passes the more this seems pretty thin. If this could be the case then thousands are daily in danger. I expect that behind the scenes this is being taken very seriously and I also suspect that given the propensity for litigation currently prevailing loose lips sink financial ships is guiding the dissemination of information i.e. what you don’t know wont hurt you (or more accurately in some cases wont hurt the company).
It seems we have reached the point predicted frequently by experts where systems too complicated to be completely analyzed have been created and are in daily world wide service.
In the design philosophy of the Airbus et al a very serious effort has been made to build in protection by redundancy but as reports come in more and more evidence of startling failures emerges of the type which warrant drastic action.
I have collected reports of a total of 52 incidents in which malfunctions of automated flight systems with computers at their core have created situations where there was a serious risk of the loss of an aircraft and all aboard. As my research has not been exhaustive likely ther are many more. Two of these situations did lead to the loss of aircraft. In one case, the crash of a B2, the crew were able to eject but the bomber worth about $250 mil was lost while in the other case – AF 447, the aircraft and all on board were lost.
Why are we continuing to fly them? In the case of the Air force and B2s the failure was diagnosed and corrected but in the case of the AF447 it is clear that in actual fact the risks are regarded as acceptable in the face of the cost of the only rational action which is to stop using these aircraft till we understand what is going on. Or am I just just being alarmist?
Read more…

Shoot the usual suspects

Author: mgiles  |  Category: Accidents, Human Factors, Human interest, Opinion

Twin Otter crash in PNG

Twin Otter crash in PNG

The recent tragic loss of a DHC 6 twin otter in PNG with the loss of at least 13 lives has brought out into the open all the usual suspects. The pilot a young PNG National has callously and unreasonably been dubbed inexperienced and the aircraft affectionately know to many as The Twatter described as poorly maintained. With these and other stories such as that the co pilot had been “forced” to fly on his day off all coming from no where it seems likely that after the ususal shock horror tsk tsk reaction an enquiry will be called and what is already is known will be pointed out (flying in PNG is very difficult, aviation infra structure has been allowed to decay to a point which would be unacceptable in many other places in the world etc) and then a few people will be blamed preferably I suspect people outside PNG such as Australia or the EU and nothing will change.
I surely hope not. It is technically possible to avoid such incidents and relatively cheap and simple so to do. Augmented GPS approaches and rotary wing transport would transform such operations as the Kokoda one with a much lower level of risk. The Augmented GPS component of this solution is available now and should be put in place with dispatch. I suppose there will be a fight over who will pay for it. Couldn’t the interested parties do it now and decide on final distribution of costs later? It would cost much less than a Stealth bomber or an AWAC.

Further action on RR Trent B 777s

Author: mgiles  |  Category: Accidents, Airlines

ba-777-heathrow-crash1

Federal regulators propose requiring modifications to engines of Boeing 777s powerd by the RR Trent engine to prevent ice from forming in fuel lines on long flights, a problem blamed for the British Airways crash last year.

The work would have to be completed by January 2011.

The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) proposed the safety directive after a similar move by European regulators called for redesigning a heat exchanger in the RR Trent engines in which engine oil is cooled and fuel heated.

About 50 such planes operate in the United States.
Read more…

Airliner falls on face

Author: mgiles  |  Category: Accidents, Airlines

Airliner on face

Airliner on face

American Airlines Inc. is assessing the damage to one of its bigger jets after the aircraft fell on its nose during maintenance work July 15.

American spokesman Tim Wagner said the Boeing 767-300ER airplane was at American’s Alliance base in Fort Worth for a heavy maintenance check.
“The maintenance had been completed,” Wagner said, “and during some of our functional tests before putting the aircraft back into service, the nose gear retracted and put the aircraft on its nose.”

The wide-body jet “has been out of service for repairs since that time,” Wagner said.
Read more…

Better Data recovery from Crashes

Author: mgiles  |  Category: Accidents, Airlines

af-447-finIn a welcome proactive step Airbus has announced a program to find better ways of recovering data in Aircraft crashes.

A 2nd of July press release has details

Airbus has launched a study for reinforcing flight data recovery, including, but not limited to, extended data transmission for commercial airliners, so that in the event of accidents, critical flight information can still be recovered and released to the investigating authorities.

Tom Enders, President and CEO of Airbus commented: “Gathering information from accidents is vitally important to further improve the safety of flying. Various technical means for reinforcing flight data recovery and data transmission to ground centres are principally available. We will now study different options for viable commercial solutions, including those where our experience with real-time data transmission from our own test aircraft could support the further development of such solutions.”

The study will be conducted by Patrick Gavin, Head of Airbus Engineering, and Charles Champion, Head of Customer Services, and will need to address technological issues as well as data protection and privacy concerns. Airbus will include industrial partners, research institutions, and international airworthiness and investigation authorities in this study.
Read more…

Pilots blame agencies for AF 447 crash

Author: mgiles  |  Category: Accidents, Airlines

Wrong priorities

Wrong priorities

Air France pilots have accused French and European air safety bodies of failing to prevent the crash of Flight 447 off Brazil last month because they ignored a history of dangerous failures in Airbus speed probes.

The Union of Air France Pilots (SPAF) made their charges amid suspicion in parts of the aviation world that French investigators, the airline and the Airbus firm may be reluctant to pinpoint a design flaw as the cause of the disaster that killed 228 people.

Their view was reinforced today when Pierre-Henri Gourgeon, chief executive of Air France, suggested that pilots’ failure to manage weather radar correctly may have led to the June 1 crash of the Rio-Paris flight.
Read more…

ATSB report: Collisions are a worry

Author: mgiles  |  Category: Accidents, Opinion

GA Collision good outcome

GA Collision good outcome

The ATSB has issued its final report into the collision which took place at Parafield in SA on 7th of February 2009. It is the usual competent, thoughtful, constructive and highly professional effort.
A number of recommendations are made which will contribute to mitigating the risk of such potentially tragic events.
Despite this I have the feeling that there is an elephant in the room and it has not been talked about.
Until now the tried and true “see and be seen” strategy has worked well. This is just as well because there has really been no alternative. Time however has passed and now it is time to recognise that a new way has to be found to address the matter of traffic avoidance.
There are a number of existing technologies which address this problem and a choice should be made and a strategy devised to incorporate appropriate new technology into the SOPs of GA.
Cost and technical difficulty will be cited as reasons not to do this but if the Aviation industry does not take the initiative others will take action and the decisions they take might not be informed and may not be optimal for anyone.